FAQ

In this section I've compiled the answers to some of the most commonly asked questions I've received over the past 20+ years as an acoustic fingerstyle guitarist.

Playing

Q: How long have you been playing guitar?

A: I started when I was 14; I got my first guitar for Christmas in 1984. I spent the next 18 years playing electric guitar in rock bands or playing acoustic as a singer-songwriter. Instrumental fingerstyle guitar didn't become my primary focus until 2002.

Q: Do you have any formal training?

A: Not really. I took a semester of classical guitar in college (I wasn't very good), but most of my previous learning was independent and very informal... I'd read books and watch other players and try to soak up as much as I could. It wasn't really an efficient approach, because there was no structure and no direction. I'd learn just enough to accomplish my immediate goals, but I missed out on a lot of valuable information that I had to go back and learn much later.

Q: How often do you practice?

A: Truly practice? Not very often at all. I don't spend much time sitting down and consciously trying to improve my technique, for example. I don't practice scales or run through any sort of exercises on a regular basis. Part of the reason for this is that I have a limited amount of time to spend on playing guitar, and I'd rather use that time working on composing or arranging. I think it also reflects the fact that I don't really consider myself a "guitarist" as much as a songwriter who happens to play guitar. In other words, I'm more interested in using the guitar as a creative outlet than I am in mastering the instrument.

Q: What got you interested in solo fingerstyle guitar?

A: Originally, it was hearing Michael Hedges' Aerial Boundaries... and his song "Bensusan" led me to discover Pierre's music as well. I was 15 or 16 at the time, and these guys just blew me away. I thought I was a decent fingerpicker because I had the Travis picking technique down, but Hedges and Bensusan opened up a whole new world of possibilities for me.

Around the same time, my uncle started taking me to The King of France Tavern in Annapolis to see Charlie Byrd play. The first time I went I had no idea who he was, but his playing absolutely mesmerized me. My uncle knew Charlie personally, so between sets he'd come over and sit at our table and chat for a bit. Those conversations with Charlie made quite an impression on me.

Although it was Hedges, Bensusan and Byrd who got me to start dabbling around with fingerstyle guitar, I was mainly playing electric guitar in bands during my teens and twenties, and it wasn't until I saw Al Petteway get pulled up on stage to play a few songs at a David Wilcox concert in 2002 that I really decided to focus on acoustic fingerstyle music. As soon as I heard Al play, I knew that was the kind of music I wanted to do. And since the long-time band I was in had dissolved at that point, I finally had the time to dedicate myself to it.

Q: What tunings do you use?

A: DADGAD has become my "standard" tuning. I use it more often than any tuning, and will often stick to DADGAD on stage when doing shorter performances. My other favorite tunings are CGDGAD and CGCGCD. I've also used slight variations of these three tunings on a few songs: DGDGAD, CGCGCE, and CGCGCEb.

Q: It looks like you only use a few right-hand fingers for picking. How did you develop that style?

A: When I first starting doing Travis-style picking, I only used the thumb plus the index and middle fingers. I did a lot of picking patterns over chord changes when playing in bands and the three-finger approach became a habit. In fact, one of the reasons I struggled so much with classical guitar was my inability to use the ring finger and pinky with any sort of consistency. I basically would have had to start over from scratch in learning right-hand technique, and I was too stubborn to do that. Still am, I guess, since I still use just three fingers most of the time. The only real exception is if I'm plucking multiple strings of a chord at the same time.

Q: Do you use natural nails or acrylics?

A: I use my natural nails, but I keep them much shorter than most fingerstyle players. Since I like a very warm, round sound, I prefer to follow Laurence Juber's example and use mostly just the flesh of the fingertips.

Q: Do you use a thumb pick?

A: No. I've gone through several periods where I've tried them, but I keep finding that I don't like the feel (or rather, the lack of feel) when using one, and I actually prefer the tone when using my thumb. A thumb pick gives me more volume, but it also yields a brighter attack with a little more "zing" to it, and I like my bass notes to be very fat and round. I also like the melody to be out on top of the bass a little bit more; when I use a thumb pick, the bass tends to step up to compete with the melody rather than accompany it. I'm sure that adjusting my technique could fix that, but I already have the balance I like without using a thumb pick. Even though forsaking the thumb pick means sacrificing some volume, I'm happier with the tone.

Q: Much of your style seems to come from left-hand technique--specifically hammer-ons and pull-offs. Do you have any advice for improving these techniques?

A: One of the reasons I use them so often is that they tend to come pretty naturally for me. I've had several students, though, that have really struggled with them, and I think there are a couple of suggestions to keep in mind when working on hammers and pulls. First, slow down and focus on making sure that you're executing them cleanly. In other words, both notes in the hammer or pull should sound clearly and at the same volume. Keeping the same volume shouldn't mean you have to execute the hammers and pulls with more force--just better technique. Don't worry about doing them fast, either... the speed will come naturally once you've got the right technique. It's more important to execute hammers and pulls cleanly rather than quickly. The second suggestion is to get all four left-hand fingers involved. You should be able to use any combination of fingers (even the pinky!) for both hammers and pulls without losing clarity or volume.

Q: Do you play any other types of music?

A: I still like to pick up an electric guitar every once in a while and play the blues or dabble in a bit of jazz. And I still enjoy grabbing an acoustic in standard tuning and strumming (and singing) all the songs I wrote for my old band. But playing solo fingerstyle guitar is challenging enough and rewarding enough to keep me occupied and satisfied.

Performing

Q: Do you get nervous before performing?

A: Sure. "Nervous" might be too strong of a word, but there are definitely a few butterflies before any performance. I think as you get used to performing the nervousness becomes more of an excited feeling—a bit of an adrenaline rush—because you always want to do your best, and there's a little anxiety about whether you'll live up to your expectations and the expectations of the audience. Those butterflies are natural, and as a performer you expect them and do your best to turn them into positive energy.

Live performances are also exciting because they're the best way to connect directly with other people and share your music—whether people in the audience are hearing you for the first time, or they're already fans who are familiar with your music. Playing live is shared experience that's uniquely different from listening to recordings, and the opportunities to interact with people during and after a performance are very rewarding.

Q: How come you don't perform more often?

A: Currently, the primary reason I'm not performing is that I'm still in the process of refamiliarizing myself with the songs after taking a lengthy break from playing/performing. It'll take a significant amount of time and dedication to make sure my "chops" are back to the same level they were 15-20 years ago and I feel comfortable performing again.

I think once I get back to the point where I'm satisfied with my playing again, I'll return to performing.

Q: How do you decide what songs to play during a performance?

A: The first thing to factor in is how much time I have to work with, since I'll structure things a bit differently for a 45-minute performance than I would for a 2-hour show. For a shorter performance, I'm also more likely to stick to a single tuning (usually DADGAD); if I have more time, I'll venture into some of the other tunings, too.

The next step is to choose songs that will compliment each other in terms of mood, pacing, key, style, etc. I want to make sure I don't do too many similar songs in a row. After that, it's simply a matter of arranging the songs in the specific order I want to play them.

If I'm using multiple tunings, I'll group them by tuning first. Sometimes I'll group them by similar capo positions, because that cuts down a little on the amount of time I spend tweaking the tuning between songs.

I've also enjoyed arranging my set list by geographical themes: I might start with a few Scottish tunes, then move to Ireland for a bit before coming back to the East Coast of the US and heading south from Maine until I arrive back home in Georgia. Many of my songs have some sort of geographical ties, so this works out rather well.

Q: I noticed that sometimes during performances you play standing up, and other times you play sitting down. Do you have a preference?

A: Not really. I think it has more to do with the type of performance I'm doing than anything else. The decision usually depends on the venue, the stage area, the type of audience, the sound system (if any), etc. Many fingerstyle guitarists prefer playing while seated, but since I spent so many years playing electric guitar, standing while playing also feels completely natural and comfortable.

Composing & Arranging

Q: What is your writing process?

A: I was a songwriter for many years while playing in bands (was always a better songwriter than guitarist, in fact) and much of my approach to writing instrumentals is the same. I still think in terms of verses, choruses, and bridges... so my song structures are somewhat predictable and familiar. I think that helps make my tunes accessible, especially to listeners who might not typically listen to instrumental guitar music.

As far as writing the actual tunes, they always start with a melody... and the melody has to be something I can hum, because I usually don't record song ideas or write them down. So I have to be able to remember them, and I'll often come up with additional parts to the song while I'm not playing guitar. The original melody will just bounce around in my head while I'm driving or doing chores around the house, and I'll get an idea for where to go next. Then I have to keep humming it until I can get to a guitar and figure out how to play it. The combination of humming and physically playing the notes on the guitar tend to be enough to keep it in my memory.

Q: How do you know when a song is finished?

A: Since I write and structure my instrumental songs much like I did when writing songs with lyrics, they tend to follow patterns in terms of where the verses, choruses and bridges fall, and tend to resolve the same way. The main difference is that with instrumental tunes, I usually keep the songs a little shorter, since the lyrical element isn't there to help maintain the listener's interest as long.

Q: What's your approach for arranging?

A: Very similar to writing... I start with the melody and build everything else around that. Of course, when arranging tunes the melody is already there to work with, so it's simply a matter of deciding how to adapt it to solo guitar. I usually try to keep the arrangement fairly simple so that the emphasis stays on the melody. After all, the tune is already very good (or I wouldn't be arranging it in the first place), so it really doesn't need any "help" from me by adding fancy guitar playing.

Q: How do you choose the songs to arrange?

A: There are two main qualities I look for when choosing tunes to arrange. Obviously, it has to be a song that I really enjoy, and it has to have a great melody. Just as important, it has to be a song that I think I can render effectively on solo guitar. For my style, this usually means that the melody has to stand up pretty well on its own, because other than fleshing out the bass line and chords, I'm probably not going to worry about an intricate arrangement that captures all of the song's original instrumentation.

Q: How do you know what tuning to use?

A: I usually want a new song or arrangement to fall into one of the tunings I already use regularly (DADGAD, CGDGAD, and CGCGCD). Obviously, there are people like Pierre Bensusan who can make anything work in DADGAD and El McMeen who can do everything in CGDGAD... but I like to let the tuning do some of the work for me, so I'll pick the familiar tuning which makes the song easiest for me to play. I'll usually start by trying the song in DADGAD, and if I like the way the melody falls beneath my fingers, I'll check to see if the bass notes also work out. Depending on the key, sometimes it's easier to switch to CGDGAD to take advantage of different open bass notes. If the melody isn't working out in one of the xxDGAD tunings, I'll try it in CGCGCD. Or sometimes—especially if I want to take advantage of droning notes, I might try CGCGCD first.

It's usually only once I've decided there's something I don't like about the way the song is working in those three tunings that I'll start adjusting other strings to address the "problem" spot. This is why some of my songs have ended up in tunings that are just minor variations of those three: DGDGAD, CGCGCE, CGCGCEb, etc.

Q: How do you decide what to play in a duet?

A: It depends on the situation—who I'm playing with (and why), and what song we're doing. On a couple of the duets I recorded with Al Petteway, "The Ride of the Red Knight" and "Dragonflies," I specifically wanted Al to play lead so I wrote in parts for myself that were strictly rhythm. On the Christmas medley we did for the Castlerea album, I wanted the focus to be on harmonies, so I wrote the melody arrangement and then gave it to Al and let him come up with a harmony part (which he did on the bouzouki). When I wrote "The Water-Crossers," I really hadn't thought about it being a duet, but as I was recording it Al kept hearing a harmony part and asked if he could add it. Of course I said yes, and now I can't imagine the song without it.

If I'm playing a duet with someone who already has a melody arrangement worked out, then I'll try to add a harmony part. It's a little more challenging—but also really fun—to come up with a complimentary part that adds something to the original arrangement. When I recorded "O Come, O Come, Emmanuel" with John Sweet, I used an open Cm tuning (CGCGCEb) to create a harmony part, and then we did something unusual by having the song start out with me playing the harmony first and John coming in with the melody later.

When Mike Golay asked me to join him for a live duet on his arrangement of "Peggy Gordon," I listened to the recorded version he had done with Al Petteway, and then came up with a harmony part that had a similar feel.

During my 2008 summer tour, Celtic guitarist John Sherman and I did a couple of duets when I was in Ohio. We sat down and ran through each tune a few times a couple of hours before we performed them. Two of the songs were completely new to me, so I mostly let John play the melodies while I did a combination of harmonies and chord accompaniment.

Finally, I've had the opportunity to do a few live duets with flatpicking champion Allen Shadd. We played "Dragonflies" and a song Allen wrote called "Sister's Waltz." In these situations, the only smart thing to do is stick to the melody and let Allen do his thing!

Recording

Q: How did you get such a natural sound on your albums?

A: Easy... I turned the recording process over to someone who really knew how to get a great acoustic guitar sound in the studio—the late Al Petteway. I know very little about recording myself, so when it was time to record I headed to Fairewood Studios and let Al work his magic.

Q: Do you ever use overdubs on your recordings?

A: No... using overdubs to enhance my parts would seem contradictory to the idea of solo fingerstyle guitar. If I can't play it live, I don't want to record it.

The exceptions to this, of course, are the duets. All of the duets I've recorded with Al have had his part overdubbed once my part was already recorded. Since we don't rehearse the duets—and in fact, the first time Al heard my parts were when they were recorded—it made sense to have Al add his parts later.

The only duet that was recorded live was "O Come, O Come Emmanuel," with John Sweet. We'd rehearsed the tune ahead of time, and it only took two or three takes to get the recording that appears on the album.

Q: How many takes of each song do you do in the studio?

A: One of the biggest luxuries of home recording is the lack of time constraints, so you're able to do an infinite number of takes (if you have the patience) until you get it just right.

In a studio environment, though, when you—or the record label—are footing the bill and time is money, it's rare to have that luxury. So it's essential to really know the tunes well before recording.

Even so, it usually requires multiple takes to get to the "sweet spot" while playing. Too few takes, and you're essentially still warming up. Too many takes, and the playing loses energy because of the repetition. Generally, I do three or four takes of each song... with the second or third take usually being the best. The first and last takes I do are almost "throw away" takes, because with the first one I'm not necessarily warmed up to the tune yet, and on the last take I know I just had a good take previously but feel compelled to do another one "just in case."

After the last take, Al and I would listen through them and decide which one has the best feel and the best playing. Then we'd use that one as "the" take, and listen to it again to see if there are any rough spots—a note that is slightly flubbed, or a (louder than normal) finger squeak, or maybe a passage that just doesn't have the same energy. Once we isolated any issues, we'd edit the track by splicing in the appropriate note(s) from one of the other takes.

It's not as ideal as playing the song perfectly in a single take, but it's a much more practical approach in the studio where you have limited time and a limited budget.

Q: If I'm reading the liner notes correctly, it appears that you recorded the Solo Guitar and Celtic Guitar albums during the same week. Isn't that, well... crazy?

A:: While I didn't think so at the time I decided to do it, yeah, I'd have to say that recording two albums in one week was a little nuts. OK, a lot nuts.

The idea, of course, was to make the most efficient use of the studio time... and I figured I had the songs down, so why not? I think I underestimated, however, just how draining it would be. I ended up recording 37 songs in a single week, which meant that I'd also spent a lot of time rehearsing those songs before going in to the studio. When you also factor in that we did multiple takes of every song and then spent time editing them, etc., it ends up taking a lot of time and energy. And since I was also doing these recordings for my first releases on Solid Air Records, there was additional stress because I wanted them to be the very best I could offer—which, of course, is very difficult when doing so much in such a short amount of time.

I ended up being very happy with the results, but I also felt burned out for a while afterwards. It's one of those things that you can say that you're proud of doing... but you'd never want to do it again. From now on, I'll stick to one record at a time!

Q: When's the next recording coming out?

A: As of now, there aren't any current plans to record. I've just recently started playing this style of music again after taking an extended break—nearly fifteen years—where I was either not playing at all, or primarily focused on playing jazz on electric guitars.

The music industry and the way people consume music has also changed significantly since I was last recording. Solid Air Records is no longer an active label, and of course Al Petteway passed away in 2023—so any future recording projects would be dramatically different from what I'm used to.

I don't know what the future holds, but right now, I'm just falling in love with acoustic fingerstyle guitar all over again, and not worrying about recording or performing.

Lessons

Q: Do you give guitar lessons?

A: As of right now, I'm not taking on any new students... but if you're interested in lessons, please reach out to me at jimtozier@gmail.com so I can contact you when I have an opening.

Guitars

Q: What makes a guitar good for playing fingerstyle?

A: Giving it to a good fingerstyle guitarist! Yes, I'm being funny... but there's a lot of truth in that, too. The guitar is probably a much smaller part of the equation than many people believe. For example, if I were to list my own preferences for a "fingerstyle guitar," you'd end up with almost the exact opposite of the guitar that Michael Hedges used (a Martin D-28), and it would be silly to suggest that he was using the wrong guitar! Ultimately, there's no "right" answer to what makes a good fingerstyle guitar.

Obviously, certain guitars are going to be better suited than others for individual players—but I think those preferences are very personal and often develop over time and with experience. The most important thing is to find a guitar that's comfortable to play. That might mean experimenting with different body sizes, scale lengths, and string spacing—but unless your current guitar is uncomfortable in some way, there really isn't a need to change.

Q: What qualities or specifications do you look for when choosing a guitar for yourself?

A: I tend to prefer smaller-bodied guitars because I find them more comfortable to play. I also find a slightly wider nut width (usually 1.75") and a fuller neck profile more comfortable to play than a narrower nut or a thinner neck.

The next thing I tend to look for is the tonal quality. I have a very light touch, so I prefer guitars that are more responsive. I'm a big fan of cedar tops because they tend to work well with my lighter attack, and they often have a little more warmth and "sweetness" than a spruce top.

Another factor I consider is the guitar's scale length. Because I mostly play in dropped tunings, a guitar with a longer scale length (25.5" or more) will retain more string tension without having to move to heavier strings, which is a plus for my playing style.

Q: It looks like your main guitars are a trio of Avalons. What made you choose Avalon guitars?

A: I have a long history with Avalon, having used a cedar/mahogany Avalon A101 to record my Solo Guitar and Celtic Guitar albums back in 2004, which led to me becoming an Avalon endorsing artist.

After recently returning to playing acoustic fingerstyle guitar, I was interested in finding a couple of guitars that were slightly smaller than my Hamblin SJ, and I knew Avalon would be able to deliver the kind of sound and workmanship I was looking for. Their guitars have a distinctly Irish voicing that is perfect for the type of music I play, and they're exquisite hand-made instruments of the highest quality.

I'd originally planned on having Avalon build a pair of guitars for me—the cedar/mahogany S15C and the cedar/rosewood S35C—but after seeing the first pictures of those guitars under construction, I decided to add a cedar/walnut S25C as well!

Q: What's the story behind the Hamblin SJ?

A: I discovered Kent Hamblin's guitars through a friend of mine back in 2005. I was so impressed with my friend's cedar/cocobolo Hamblin SJ that I ended up buying it from him and ordering two additional SJ guitars from Kent—one in cedar/mahogany and one in cedar/rosewood.

I sold all three Hamblins around the same time I took an extended break from playing—but several years later, my oldest son, Owen, found the cedar/mahogany SJ listed for sale online (it was easily identifiable because my signature is inlaid on the back of the headstock) and bought it for me as a surprise Father's Day gift.

The Hamblin has too much sentimental value now to be used as my main guitar, but it still gets played frequently and will end up being passed back to Owen one day. If someone reading this happens to know where the other two Hamblins are, I'd love to keep tabs on them. The cedar/cocobolo SJ was featured on the cover of my Celtic Guitar Solos songbook and has a unique spalted maple rosette, and the cedar/rosewood SJ will be even easier to identify since it also has my signature on the back of the headstock.

Q: Is your Taylor 514 one of the guitars you used to record Castlerea?

A: No, I only acquired the 514 recently—but I picked it up because it's very similar to the Taylors I used back then. The four Taylors I used to record Castlerea were a 1998 714ce (cedar/rosewood), a 1999 514ce (cedar/mahogany), a 1999 W14c (cedar/walnut), and a 2001 714ce-ltd (cedar/cocobolo).

The 514 is a 2002 model—so it's from the same era, but has the advantage of not having the old Fishman Prefix electronics system that was standard on most Taylors at the time. I've really grown to dislike having any kind of electronics built into the sides of my acoustic guitars. I prefer soundhole controls—or no onboard controls at all—for guitars equipped with pickups. It's hard to find older Taylors without the Fishman electronics, so this one immediately caught my eye when I was looking for another cedar-topped guitar to play while I was waiting for my Avalons to arrive.

Q: Can you tell me a little about your Pono guitar?

A: I found the Pono O-20 when I was looking for a "couch/travel/songwriting" guitar that was small enough to carry around and play comfortably whenever (and wherever) inspiration struck—or in any situation where I didn't want to risk using one of my more expensive guitars.

The Pono caught my eye because of the cedar top (of course!), and it also has solid mahogany back and sides and real ebony bindings—while most guitars in this price range have laminated back and sides and plastic bindings. Pono is better known for making ukeleles than guitars, and are Indonesian-made versions of Ko'olau instruments that are made in Hawai'i—which helps keep costs down.

I was only vaguely familiar with Pono before trying this guitar, and was really impressed by the quality and value of an all-solid-wood guitar that was perfectly suited for the role I had in mind. Because of its small size and big sound, it's quite fun to play!

Strings & Accessories

Q: What strings do you use on your guitars?

A: I've become a big fan of D'Addario XS Phosphor Bronze strings, and I use them on all of my guitars. XS strings are coated, which gives them a smoother feel and a much longer lifespan than regular uncoated strings. Yes, they're more expensive—but they last so long that I actually end up spending less money (and less time) on strings in the long run.

I use the XS Phosphor Bronze because I like a little warmer/mellower tone, and my default gauge is the 12-53 Light, which are great all-around strings that work well in all of the various tunings I use (including standard).

Because D'Addario also offers their customizable Player's Choice option, it's also easy to tailor sets that are optimized for individual tunings. If I know I'll leave a guitar in DADGAD or CGDGAD tuning, I'll use a custom set that replaces the 1st, 2nd, and 6th strings (the three strings that get dropped down from standard in those tunings) with the strings from the next highest gauge set in order to keep more tension on the strings.

Likewise, for my CGCGCD tuning—where several strings are tuned down but the 2nd string is tuned up to C, it helps to be able to customize a set that doesn't feel too loose on the dropped strings or too taut on the raised 2nd string.

Q: What capos do you use?

A: I really like the D'Addario Artist Capo, because it combines functionality with precision. It has a trigger design that's easy to use with one hand and clamps on the headstock of my guitar when not in use, and the adjustable tension and flexible padding make sure that just the right amount of pressure is applied while keeping the guitar in tune. I store one of these capos in the case of every guitar I own.

For my song "Trinity," which is played with three capos on the guitar at the same time, I use special capos that only cover certain strings. I use a standard capo on the 2nd fret, a "Drop D" capo (which covers everything except the 6th string) on the 4th fret, and a "DADGAD" capo (which covers the 3rd, 4th, and 5th strings) on the 7th fret. I have a bunch of these specialized capos on hand—some of which were designed that way and some of which I made myself by cutting up standard capos. I'm hoping D'Addario will offer these in their Artist capo lineup at some point.

Castlerea Celtic Guitar Solo Guitar Guitar Pieces Live in Little Rock Celtic Guitar Solos A Guitar for Elvis Poppin' Guitars Delovely Guitar